Re: SqString

Hi there,

Before SqString patch applied, squid3 looked stable, I had days to see a
problem.
The SqString had unpredicted effects in squid3 like the bug 1970. And
maybe there are other issues not appeared yet. It was not enough
analyzed before applied.

Regards,
     Christos

PS. Last weekend, my squid3 crashed again and again with segmentation
faults or assertions, in different places not allowing me to understand
where the problem is. OK, maybe happens because of bad compilation after
changes applied, but I am not absolutely sure....
However, I don't have such problems any more...

Henrik Nordstrom wrote:
> Should we back out SqString for now until the implicit cast issues have
> been analyzed in more detail, or try fixing it somehow for the 3.0
> release?
>
> http://www.squid-cache.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=1970
>
> My vote is to defer the SqString change to 3.1, or at least after 3.0
> has been branched from HEAD.
>
> Reasoning: More work is required to polish it, and it doesn't really add
> anything to the 3.0 release (beyond the bugfixes it triggered
> indirectly), mainly preparation for future work.
>
> Regards
> Henrik
>
Received on Thu May 24 2007 - 07:02:28 MDT